After Amazon abandoned its proposed Queens headquarters in 2019, Governor Andrew Cuomo forced through a change to PACB’s voting rules in the state budget. A financing requirement already existed; the added provision expressly limits members’ voting authority to whether sufficient funds are committed for the project.
That provision also lets the Governor immediately remove a member whom the Governor finds is acting, or threatening to act, beyond that financing role. This is why specific questions about funding commitments, costs, and financial risks matter when contacting PACB members.
S2459 / A8569 is sponsored by Senator Leroy Comrie in the Senate and Assemblymember Edward C. Braunstein in the Assembly. It would remove the 2019 restriction on members’ votes and the Governor’s power under that provision to remove members for going beyond the financing question.
PACB would still have to check that enough money is committed to pay for the project. The bill would remove the added limits on members’ ability to exercise independent judgment.
Why we support it: removing those limits would strengthen independent oversight and could give our community’s concerns more weight when BMT financing is reviewed.
Governor Kathy Hochul vetoed an earlier repeal bill, S521, on November 17, 2023.
Status checked September 30, 2026: S2459 passed both houses, with Assembly passage on June 4, 2026. The Senate’s official action history does not yet list delivery to the Governor, a signature, or a veto. The proposed repeal has not taken effect.
Sources: Senate sponsor’s memo: the 2019 change was enacted at Governor Andrew Cuomo’s demand · April 2019 reporting on the Amazon dispute and PACB change.